The turkeyfoot creek creamery ice cream recall started on June 11, 2025, when the family-owned business in Wauseon, Ohio, took quick action to protect customers. They pulled seven popular ice cream flavors from stores because of undeclared allergens. No one has reported getting sick, and the company removed every affected pint from shelves fast. This move shows how small creameries put safety first.
Understanding the Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery Ice Cream Recall
The turkeyfoot creek creamery ice cream recall covers all pints of these flavors: Avalanche, Chocolate Peanut Butter, Chocolate Strawberry, Chocolate Brownie Bites, Cookies and Cream, Cookie Dough, and Cacao and Mocha. Each one comes in a simple paper carton with a paper lid. The problem? Some labels missed listing key allergens like soy, wheat, or peanuts in the “Contains” statement.
Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery makes small batches in their clean facility in Wauseon. They started with goat cheese years ago and later added artisan ice cream sweetened with maple syrup. The turkeyfoot creek creamery ice cream recall happened after they found the labeling mistake during a routine check. They told the Ohio Department of Agriculture right away and worked with stores to clear the shelves.
Stores in these places carried the pints before the turkeyfoot creek creamery ice cream recall: six locations in Canton, Cleveland, West Unity, and Arlington, Ohio, plus one store in Fort Wayne, Indiana, and one in Hudson, Michigan. By June 11, every single carton was off the shelves. You cannot buy these flavors there now.
Exact Products in the Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery Ice Cream Recall
Here is the full list from the official notice: • Avalanche Artisan Ice Cream – one pint – undeclared soy and wheat • Chocolate Peanut Butter Artisan Ice Cream – one pint – undeclared soy • Chocolate Strawberry Artisan Ice Cream – one pint • Chocolate Brownie Bites Artisan Ice Cream – one pint • Cookies and Cream Artisan Ice Cream – one pint • Cookie Dough Artisan Ice Cream – one pint • Cacao and Mocha Artisan Ice Cream – one pint
Each carton holds 473 ml. The turkeyfoot creek creamery ice cream recall includes every lot sold in those stores during the weeks before June 11, 2025. Check your freezer for any paper carton with “Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery” on the front. If you see one of these flavors, it is part of the turkeyfoot creek creamery ice cream recall.
Why Undeclared Allergens Matter So Much
Allergens are ingredients that can cause serious reactions in some people. The eight major ones are milk, eggs, fish, crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, and soybeans. Sesame became the ninth in 2023. Even tiny amounts can make a child or adult very sick.
In the turkeyfoot creek creamery ice cream recall, the missing labels mean someone with a soy or wheat allergy might not know the risk. Chocolate Peanut Butter likely uses peanut butter that contains soy. Avalanche has mix-ins with wheat and soy. The company fixed the labels for future batches, but the turkeyfoot creek creamery ice cream recall protects anyone who already bought the older pints.
What to Do If You Bought Products from the Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery Ice Cream Recall
Follow these easy steps:
- Look in your freezer for any Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery pint with the flavors listed above.
- Do not eat it.
- Take it back to the store where you bought it for a full refund – no receipt needed.
- If you threw away the carton, you can still call the store or the creamery.
- Wash your hands after handling the carton.
Call Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery at 419-583-7124 with any questions. They answer quickly and help with refunds or more details. The turkeyfoot creek creamery ice cream recall team wants every family to feel safe.
Health Signs to Watch After Eating Ice Cream
Most people who ate these pints feel fine. Still, know the signs of an allergic reaction: • Hives or itchy skin • Swelling of lips or face • Trouble breathing • Stomach pain or vomiting • Feeling dizzy
If any of these happen, call a doctor right away or go to the nearest clinic. For severe cases, use an EpiPen if you have one and call 911. The good news? No illnesses have been linked to the turkeyfoot creek creamery ice cream recall so far.
Who Is Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery?
Del Burkholder started Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery on his family farm in Wauseon, Ohio, around 2011. He grew up with goats and learned farming from his parents in Fulton County. Painting jobs hurt his lungs, so he turned to making cheese full time. His farm became the only goat-cheese maker in northwest Ohio that uses milk from its own herd.
Customers love the fresh taste. Del offers farm tours and samples. Over the years, the creamery added small-batch ice cream made with care. They use maple syrup instead of regular sugar for a special flavor. The turkeyfoot creek creamery ice cream recall does not change the fact that this is a trusted local business that cares about quality.
For more stories on Ohio’s local food makers, check out Ohio dairy insights.
How This Recall Compares to Others
The turkeyfoot creek creamery ice cream recall is small and fast – only pints in a few Midwest stores. Other recalls were bigger. In 2025, Breyers recalled over 6,000 cases because Rocky Road was put in Chocolate Truffle tubs with wrong labels about almonds. No one got sick there either.
Another 2025 case involved Mochidoki mochi ice cream sold at Aldi. They missed wheat and soy on over 40,000 cartons. Again, quick action stopped problems. The turkeyfoot creek creamery ice cream recall fits the pattern of careful small makers fixing issues before anyone gets hurt.
Biggest Ice Cream Recalls in U.S. History
Many big recalls happen for different reasons. Here are some key ones: • Blue Bell Creameries in 2015 recalled everything nationwide after listeria made ten people sick, with three deaths. • Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams in 2015 pulled over 500,000 pounds after listeria showed up in one plant – no one got sick because they acted fast. • Big Olaf Creamery in 2022 recalled all products after 28 illnesses and one death from listeria.
These show why companies like Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery watch every detail. Read the full list of major cases in this helpful roundup of biggest ice cream recalls.
Why Allergen Recalls Happen More Often Now
Since the 2004 labeling law, companies must list the big allergens clearly. In 2023, sesame joined the list. Today, undeclared allergens cause about 57 percent of all food recalls. Small creameries sometimes miss a line when they add new mix-ins. The turkeyfoot creek creamery ice cream recall reminds everyone to double-check labels.
Simple Tips for Safe Ice Cream at Home •
Always read the “Contains” statement, even if you bought the same flavor before. • Keep a list of your family’s allergies on the fridge. • Buy from places that keep good records. • Freeze ice cream at 0°F or colder. • When in doubt, throw it out.
These steps help you enjoy treats without worry. The turkeyfoot creek creamery ice cream recall proves that clear labels save lives.
What the Recall Means for Small Creameries
Small places like Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery make special flavors that big factories cannot match. One mistake on a label can hurt trust, but quick fixes build it back stronger. Del and his team showed they care by announcing the turkeyfoot creek creamery ice cream recall right away. Customers who love local food still support them because safety comes first.
Food Safety Rules That Protect You
The FDA and Ohio Department of Agriculture work together. When a problem appears, companies must tell them within 24 hours for serious issues. Stores pull products fast. The turkeyfoot creek creamery ice cream recall followed every rule perfectly. No Class I (high danger) rating here – it is a lower-risk fix for labels.
Stories from People Who Choose Local Ice Cream
Families in Ohio say they pick Turkeyfoot Creek pints because they know the farm. Kids enjoy Cookie Dough on hot days. Parents feel good buying from a neighbor. The turkeyfoot creek creamery ice cream recall did not change that love – it showed the business puts health above everything.
How to Check Your Freezer Today
Take five minutes right now. Open the freezer door. Look for any Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery carton. Match the flavors. If you find one, put it in a bag and take it back to the store tomorrow. Tell the manager it is part of the turkeyfoot creek creamery ice cream recall. They know what to do and will give your money back with a smile.
Why Quick Action Matters
When Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery learned about the missing allergens, they did not wait. They called stores, told the state, and posted the notice on June 11, 2025. That speed means almost no risk reached families. Other companies study cases like the turkeyfoot creek creamery ice cream recall to improve their own checks.
Allergen Facts Every Parent Should Know About 1 in 13 kids has a food allergy. Reactions can start in minutes. Soy hides in many chocolate products. Wheat appears in brownie bits or cookie pieces. Reading labels every single time keeps kids safe. The turkeyfoot creek creamery ice cream recall gives us all a gentle reminder.
Looking Ahead for Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery The creamery already updated every label. New pints will show every allergen clearly. Fans can keep enjoying their favorite flavors with extra peace of mind. The turkeyfoot creek creamery ice cream recall is now history, but the lessons stay.
More Ways Recalls Help the Whole Industry Every recall teaches factories better cleaning and labeling steps. Big brands and small farms share ideas. The result? Safer ice cream for everyone. The turkeyfoot creek creamery ice cream recall adds one more success story of a company doing the right thing fast.
Easy Checklist for Grocery Shopping • Pick pints with clear “Contains” statements. • Choose brands you trust. • Ask store staff if you see new flavors. • Buy smaller sizes first to test.
These habits reduce chances of any future surprises.
Supporting Local Farms After a Recall Many people in Ohio still visit Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery for cheese and new safe ice cream. Your support helps family farms stay strong. Next time you shop, look for their updated pints. The turkeyfoot creek creamery ice cream recall showed they deserve that trust.
Common Questions About the Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery Ice Cream Recall Can I still eat other flavors? Yes – only the seven listed are part of the recall. Is goat milk ice cream different? This recall used standard cream, but the farm’s goat cheeses stay unchanged. Will prices go up? No – the company fixed the issue without extra cost to customers.
Summary of the Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery Ice Cream Recall The turkeyfoot creek creamery ice cream recall of June 2025 was small, fast, and handled perfectly. Seven flavors in a handful of Midwest stores had missing allergen info. Every pint came off shelves, and no one got sick. Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery proved once again that local makers put your family first.
Check your freezer today, return any matching pints, and enjoy safe treats from trusted farms. Have you seen the updated Turkeyfoot Creek labels in your store yet? Share in the comments how you stay safe with ice cream.
References
- Ohio Department of Agriculture. (2025, June 11). Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery Issues Voluntary Recall of Ice Cream for Undeclared Allergens. https://agri.ohio.gov/divisions/dairy/recalls/turkeyfoot-creek-creamery-recall-ice-cream-6-2025
- Tasting Table. (2025, June 10). 12 Of The Biggest Ice Cream Recalls In U.S. History. https://www.tastingtable.com/1882077/biggest-ice-cream-recalls-us-history/
- Infectious Disease Advisor. (2025). More Than 110,000 Rich’s Ice Cream Bars Recalled Due to Listeria Risk. https://www.infectiousdiseaseadvisor.com/news/more-than-110000-richs-ice-cream-bars-recalled-due-to-listeria-risk/
- The Healthy. (2025, July 21). More Ice Cream Recalled in a Total of 4 States. Details on Turkeyfoot Creek Creamery products and allergens.